Crypto is fine art


I’ve come to think of crypto as almost exactly parallel to the “fine art” market. You start with decoupling value from utility and accept “the value of something is what someone will pay for it.” And, in the age of mechanical and digital reproduction (aka forgery), the only inherent quality that defines "what someone will pay" is its uniqueness.  Rembrandt isn’t painting any more canvases. A painting believed to be a Rembrandt and then it turns out to have been done by one of his students plummets in price (or vice versa) not because of any aesthetic issue (people who are very well-compensated experts may argue the issue) but because of the combination of reputation and constrained supply.

Coupled with that quality is the collective social value, which is, but for the tiniest whiff, entirely subjective. Post-modern art has devalued aesthetics and elevated ephemerality. A banana duct-taped to a wall is worth millions only to the extent that it was the first one ever duct-taped to the wall at a prestigious show.

But consider the size of “the art world” that exists to maintain that collective social value. Starting with modernism, they’ve foregone widespread appeal (“that’s a great rendering of a pretty scene”) to sustaining appeal in the moneyed class (“my kid could do that,” but yeah, your kid wasn’t part of the Manhattan scene in 1958).

Returning to crypto, it’s the same thing. The initial widespread appeal was “that’s a great way to transfer money internationally without fees, taxes, or traceability” has been subsumed by “yeah, your kid could start a blockchain, but he wasn’t part of the Reddit scene in 2008.” Or, in the case of Trump and his “memecoins,” the collective social appeal of being associated with the great man himself.

The Bitcoin blockchain is still valued at $1.3T even with the current drawdown. I think that’s a big enough pool of collective capital endorsement to create a “the ~~art~~ crypto world“ supporting secondary market. Now that BTC has moved into retirement ETFs (I don’t know if that’s happened or is just imminent) it becomes “too big to fail,” aka the capital class becomes complicit in maintaining its social value.