"You Can See Everything" is a straightforward movie. It's a 3 hour struggle with the question "Is 'Elizabeth Holmes' a character or a neurodivergent victim of manipulation?" Headlines speak of "shocking" scenes but the most shocking scene for me was a discussion about Abbott and Costello's "Who's on first?"
"Is 'Nathan Fielder' a character or is he neurodivergent?" is a constant question in Fielder's TV shows. In his shows, Fielder has presented as a low-affect straightman committed to his own "logical" ideas who, at least seemingly, has trouble reading people's reactions to his absurdities.
mild spoilers ahead...
In "Nathan Fielder For You," Fielder "solved" the problems of small businesses, often depending upon the strict reading of the law: setting up a gas station to sell gas for $1.75 (but only if you drop your rebate certificate in a box at the end of an hours-long hike), converting a coffee shop into "Shitty Starbucks," relying on the legal protections for satire and generating around-the-block lines (who wouldn't want a "Shitty Starbucks" mug?), and the like. In "The Rehearsal," he addresses a single problem with an absurd idea and halfway through the season doubles-down with a jaw-dropping escalation. I think he's brilliant.
The 'Nathan Fielder' of the TV shows is definitely a character to a significant degree. The actor Nathan Fielder never breaks character, at least not on camera. In "You Can See Everything," Elizabeth Holmes never breaks, at least not during the hundreds of hours filmed by the "You Can See Everything," crew. The Nathan Fielder of "You Can See Everything," is an insightful documentarian struggling to understand Elizabeth Holmes. He has more screen time than anyone else, even if many shots are him silently watching.
Enough of Fielder. Elizabeth Holmes was 19 years old when she founded Theranos, along with her then-partner Sunny Baldwani who was 38. I mention ages because it seems plausible, barely, that Baldwani was a Svengali who manipulated her into lying about the Theranos machine's ability. In "You Can See Everything," she presents as a signicantly neurodivergent person who does not understand such things as clear lies or why "Who's On First?" is funny.
Holmes is very smart. She earned a patent for a drug-delivery patch while an undergraduate chemical engineering student at Stanford. Manipulated or not, she was the CEO and public face of a startup eventually valued at 9 billion dollars. Holmes is very charismatic. She raised money from men like Jim Mattis (who eventually became Secretary of Defense), the former CEO of Wells Fargo, Rupert Murdoch, and a bunch of former senators. Not people who cut checks for tens of millions of dollars casually.
The Holmes of "You Can See Everything," is bafflingly obtuse; she refuses to acknowledge the difference between the conditional 'can' ("You can drive this car anywhere," conditional on fixing the currently destroyed transmission) vs. the categorical 'can' ("You can fit ten bags of groceries in this car's trunk."). Is that plausible in a person of her accomplishments?
The Holmes of "You Can See Everything," is highly passive. Is it "just" that she's understandably overwhelmed by a ten year jail sentence starting in a matter of days? Is it "just" the crafting of the documentarian? Given the legal vetting of the movie, I don't think Fielder could be presenting a Herzogian 'Ecstatic Truth.' But what was she like on the many phone calls to her own defense lawyers that pepper the movie?)
The plausability of Holmes being a highly manipulated person who had no fraudulent intention is boosted by the film's depiction of Holmes current partner, Billy Evans. Not only is 'Billy Evans' not a persona, the movie is so unsparing in its depiction of him that I can't believe the lawyers would allow the movie to be released if there was evidence that he's anything but a greedy and controlling monster who doesn't care a thing for Holmes.
The movie's last third revolves around a "Did she know?" issue related to the movie itself. We know that Billy Evans knew a truth while, at a different time, on film, Holmes asserts the opposite. Holmes was called away during the critical minutes. Was she called away strategically so that she'd have 'plausible deniability'?
Absent "The Jinx," crime documentaries never fully establish guilt or innocence. The last lines of the movie are from Nathan Fielder reflecting on his own inability to judge her: "I'm not trying to put my emotions into [that judgement]. I'm just trying to be accurate."
Such are the limits of knowledge.